I love a jealous Scully (and a jealous Mulder for that matter – some of these stories have a bit of both). Scully will be the last one to admit she’s acting jealous or territorial, but it can be difficult for her to hide it from other people.
This is a list of fics in my always-expanding fanfic library that I’ve tagged as Scully jealousy. I’ve also made this a combined first-times list by marking stories where they get it on for the first time with a ¹.
Here you’ll find lots of Scullyangst, a bit of Drunk!Scully, some two-can-play-at-this-game!Scully, and a personal favourite, I’ve-had-enough-of-Mulder’s-bullshit!Scully.
Table last updated 2020-05-18 20:41:57 by i-dont-wanna-wrestle.
| Author/s | Title | Words | Summary | Rated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13starbuck42 | (In)Visible | 1978 | Prompt: Mulder discovers how jealous Scully is of Diana... he takes it upon himself to make sure she knows how important she is to him. | T |
| AllyCarson | Sweet Revenge | 6256 | Scully undergoes a transformation that surprises even Mulder when Phoebe Green comes back into their lives. | PG |
| Angel LeeAnn | Consequences | 12061 | Mulder's one-night stand brings with it consequences that will effect him for the rest of his life. Scully, of course, is willing to stand by him through it all. | PG |
| Angel-Wings Gaskins | All I Can't Say | 1599 | Another woman takes Scully's place in Mulder's life and heart. | PG |
| AngelaW | Seduces Me¹ | 8786 | A story about love and jealousy. | N |
| Annakins02 | Chasing Fire¹ | 8587 | She could stop this right now, and their partnership would remain beyond reproach. There would be a few awkward weeks, but they'd put this night in the box labeled 'Things Never to Talk About,' and they'd move on. Like they always do. Except, she'd die an old, lonely maid because there would never be another man who could set her soul on fire the way Mulder does. She'd always be chasing that fire. | E |
| Annette Gisby | Letting Go¹ | 1884 | Relieving some tension. | N |
| Caroline | Hurting¹ | 9248 | The aftermath of Two Fathers, One Son. A jealous Scully goes out of control. | N |
| Caroline | Dressed by Armani¹ | 11841 | When Mulder poses for a GQ calendar, Scully realises how many women are after her man, and decides its time to take some action. | N |
| Caroline O | Lure of the Fox¹ | 43292 | Mulder and Scully pursue a serial killer who calls himself 'The Fox'. [There's a bit of jealousy from both of them in this one.] | N |
| CarolineMcKenna | Beer, Eveningwear and Vampires | 12344 | Mulder's ex-wife returns and is in immediate danger. Mulder is forced to make some choices between a life he used to have and the one he dreams of. Meanwhile, Scully deals with her own personal demons-jealousy and denial. | PG |
| Cerulian | Sweet Revenge¹ | 3913 | Mulder is happy. He has a date. [But he's a bit of a slimeball IMHO.] Scully is not happy. She takes revenge. | N |
| ChaneenW | Blinded by Foul Play | 22160 | Finding Samantha has given Mulder the happily ever after he'd been searching for most of his life, but Scully can't help but wonder where she fits into it now. | T |
| Chibiness87 | Heterochromia | 1703 | Mulder calls her to say the town is being attacked by a plague of killer cockroaches. Of course it is, she thinks. The day ends in 'Y'. | T |
| ChristinaSimmons | Mizpah | 6531 | Scully discovers the truth about Mulder and Diana Fowley's shared past. | PG |
| ChristinaSimmons | The Other Woman | 9634 | Having struggled to come to terms with Diana Fowley's presence in her partner's life in Mizpah, Scully is forced to confront more than a presence, and to determine where her own feelings are leading her. | PG |
| DashaK & Plausible Deniability | The Professional¹ | 56266 | A woman from Mulder's past returns, desperately needing his and Scully's help. | N |
| DianaBattis | Catalytic Converter¹ | 14278 | Mulder plays Good Samaritan. | N |
| Donna | Other Women | 3068 | That communication thing | R |
| Donnilee | J is for Jealousy¹ | 52675 | Scully is forced to admit her jealousy when she sees her nemesis kissing Mulder. They fight and then, well, they kiss and make up. A weird case provides time alone and they finally take the relationship to a new level. There's also a sequel, "Jealous Rival". | E |
| Donnilee | All Mulder's Women¹ | 11560 | Scully overhears Mulder making plans for a dinner date and has a bad reaction. Mrs. Scully convinces her to reveal her feelings before there aren't any more tomorrows. | N |
| Eddie Edora | A Girl For Mulder | 8718 | Mulder starts dating someone, and it isn't Scully. She, in turn, decides that two can play the dating game. Plenty of MSR and UST in this one. The shoe's on the other foot in "A Guy for Scully" at the same link. | PG |
| EmilySim | Relationship Redux | 5334 | Scully's a bridesmaid at Charlies wedding. Written for the Haven flashback challenge. | R |
| Elizabeth Ann Fanfic | What A Tangled Web We Weave | 6442 | An unwelcome third party causes disruption in the agents' partnership. | T |
| Emmy | Old Secrets | 4033 | Jealousy, Alcohol and Honesty | PG |
| Eponine119 | The Ex | 3018 | Scully doesn't know why she's so upset after meeting Mulder's ex-wife. [Diana is Karen for some reason, and there's a rather humourous Tom Cruise reference.] | PG |
| Eponine119 | Hey Jealousy | 6538 | Trouble leaving Comity. | R |
| FatCat | A Friend Like That¹ | 23473 | A huge fight between Mulder and Scully helps them understand just what they mean to each other and who their true friends really are. | N |
| FatCat | Yes I Am | 10302 | Mulder discovers a secret side of Scully he never dreamed existed. | PG |
| fragilevixen | XII¹ | 270850 | A killer romanticizes each and every victim, leaving behind symbols of his "love"...but who is his intended target? | M |
| Frangipani downunder | The Buck Hills Cave Incident¹ | 4824 | A case based on a real newspaper report in the Bells Cove Coronet about the Buck Hills Cave in Virginia. | E |
| Hurricane Scully | Drunk | 5146 | These are all mini separate stories about Scully being drunk. I love the idea of our in control agent being less than in control of herself 😉 [Jealous Scully is in chapter 2.] | E |
| Invisigoth421 | The Only One I Trust | 3916 | After Fight The Future the truth about Diana Fowley emerges. | T |
| Jay | The Dare |The Test |The Challenge¹ | 7502 | It begins as just another case but ends with a challenge. | N |
| JessicaKurr | Somebody To You¹ | 19170 | Mulder and Scully end up stranded in a cabin during a snowstorm, forcing them to open up to each other about what they both have really been feeling all these years. Nothing like below freezing temperatures, miscommunication, and jealousy peeling back all the layers of anger to get to the raw truth of what's really going on deep down inside of them. | M |
| JMoonrise | Through the Window | 4232 | Scully doesn't appreciate how Dakota Whitney tried to touch her man. | R |
| Kate Gayle | Never Say Never Again | 4553 | Scully catches Mulder in a compromising position. Later, when he is injured, they have to sort out their feelings for each other. | PG |
| Katherine Benton | What Doesn't Kill Us Series | 90531 | Mulder and Scully struggle with issues of trust and betrayal during and after the events after Fight the Future. | PG |
| Katie Philips | I Was Thinking About You | 10900 | This story stays true to The X-Files series up through Mulder and Scully's disagreement over Diana Fowley. At that point, I take our two heroes on a different journey... | PG |
| Lark | Anger And Jealousy | 2851 | When Scully ponders the events in One Son, she comes to some realizations. | T |
| Leyla Harrison | Eyes Open | 2516 | Scully, feeling left out and a little bitter, wishes that she could take back what she's seen. | T |
| LiliBlue | Together Apart | 12834 | Mulder and Scully slowly drift apart. A painful event reunites them after three years. | M |
| Lisa | A Case of You | 1765 | Jealousy gets the best of Scully. | PG |
| MacSpooky | Leaving Comity | 2024 | What happened after Mulder and Scully left the wonderful town of Comity. | R |
| Madeleine Partous | Floaters¹ | 22623 | Mulder and Scully investigate a case in Florida. Season 3. | M |
| Maiden Jedi | Two Truths | 1514 | Mulder contemplates two truths. | PG |
| Mezzosoprano | Don't It Make My Blue Eyes Green¹ | 7922 | A childhood friend helps Scully in her battle with the green-eyed monster. | N |
| Michelle Kiefer | Marginal | 3703 | Diana was a friend.... comfortable.... It would be so much easier if he loved her back, but he didn't. | R |
| Michelle Kiefer & Kel | Bone Of Contention | 41949 | When an investigation in the middle of nowhere opens old wounds, 2000 miles away becomes too close to home. Can Mulder and Scully unravel the puzzle before they fall apart? | R |
| Missy Pennington | Hardball | 19750 | There's competition for Mulder. | T |
| MoJo | Girl 77¹ | 5867 | Resolving sexual tension - summer smut | N |
| MonaLisa | Ashlyn¹ | 20011 | The course of true love never did run smooth | N |
| Monika FileFan | Consorting¹ | 6771 | A small collection of instances where Mulder and Scully consort with one another in their hotel rooms. See chapter 3: Ask for early MSR jealousy smut, and you shall receive. A twist on a scene in the episode Fire where Scully pays Mulder a visit in his room. | E |
| Monika FileFan | Feeding The Rumor Mill | 6034 | Mulder gets angry after overhearing a conversation about himself. Takes place during Season 5. | T |
| Monika FileFan & WildwingSuz | Green-Eyed | 5035 | What caused that switch to be flicked for Scully to see Mulder the way she discusses in The Rain King's bathroom conversation? Scully becomes jealous while assigned to the bullpen with Mulder. | T |
| Monika FileFan | Mishaps and Mistletoe | 5386 | Two days before Christmas, Scully overhears a phone call that could potentially put a freeze on her and Mulder's slow burning relationship. | T |
| MsAM | You Hurt Me¹ | 2481 | Learning to forgive and to heal | R |
| NaridaLaw | Unscrupulous | 2668 | Mulder's haircut is, quite simply, the result of one woman's possessive nature. | PG |
| NicoleMason | Grief & Consequences | 9204 | It's not a good time, post Paper Clip. | N |
| NikkiLeF | Fifteen Minute Window¹ | 6737 | A New Year's Eve party provides some Scully/Mulder angst, and a way for our two fave agents to get naughty. | N |
| nowwhat einstein | Now That You're Around Me | 3452 | Warning: This story contains the following tropes: FBI Ball! Diana Fowley-as-Satan! Jealous Scully! First Kiss! And more! If you're looking for well-worn tropes, you've come to the right place. Enjoy! | G |
| odamaebrown | How to ruin your love life | 2429 | Scully is jealous, angry and bored. | G |
| Pam Gamble | Enough¹ | 7247 | Scully attempts to deal with her jealousy of the other woman in Mulder's life - and it's not who you might think. Fifth season, before The End. | N |
| PD | The Woman in the Mirror Series¹ | 18806 | Gin and tonic is a lovely drink. Don't you agree? But it should be enjoyed in the sunlight among friends. Scully is in a dark place. Sadly, PD has finally removed her website. If you'd like a copy of this story, please use the contact form & I can email it to you, or you can be sneaky and grab the zip file from the wayback machine. | R |
| Piper Sargasso | All The Pretty Flowers¹ | 9543 | I know heartbreak. | N |
| RussianWolf7 | Playing with Fire | 7076 | Phoebe Green comes back. Of course, Scully gets really jealous, especially when things get serious between Mulder and Green. | PG |
| ScottMiller | Among the Moonbeams | 3160 | There's a party going on upstairs, and what are you doing? Sitting in a stuffy basement office reading? | T |
| ScullyLoves Queequeg | Confession¹ | 6811 | Scully begins to question her place in Mulder's life when she discovers that Mulder has another friend he's been travelling to New York to see. | E |
| Shawen A Greer | Image¹ | 10844 | A new case brings Mulder face to face with a mysterious stranger who forces him to deal with his secret desires as well as revealing some of Scullys as well. | M |
| Spacesouffles | What's Left of Us | 2680 | Post and during One Son. Dana reconsiders her position in both the FBI and in Agent Mulder's life. Is she really needed to stick around and watch him fawn over 'Special Agent' Diana Fowley. The reconsideration leads to some revelations that may push the very existence of their friendship and relationship. [WIP - possibly abandoned.] | M |
| Spock | The Unattainable? | 5412 | Scully thinks Mulder is in love with someone else, angst ensues. | PG |
| Spooky66 | Untouched¹ | 4384 | Scully relaxes after a day of being pissed at Mulder | M |
| StarCannon | A Couple Of Rebels | 1729 | Scully comes back from vacation to learn that Mulder has made an unfortunate drunken decision. | G |
| StefDavies | War: Fallout | 3031 | War of the Coprophages post-ep. | PG |
| SummerM | Secrets | 3590 | It involves the Diana shenanigans. | T |
| Taylor | The Colombian Exchange¹ | 32064 | It's a story about coffee, terrorism, love, sex, and families, though not necessarily in that order. What happens when a third agent is assigned to the X-Files - a female agent? What happens when Mulder starts dating that agent? What happens when Scully requests a transfer? Cancer rears its ugly head, as does Bill Scully, Jr. | N |
| TBishop | Best Friends Series¹ | 40407 | Scully's feelings for her partner are forced out into the open when another woman comes into the picture. | N |
| Trixie | Territorial¹ | 6810 | Basically it's some angst & fluff cleverly disguised so an excuse exists to let Moose & Squirrel have some fun, post Alpha 🙂 | N |
| trycee | The Jealousy of A Goddess¹ | 9232 | What if Scully wasn't so accepting of Karen Berquist at the end of Alpha. And what if Mulder confronted her about it? Would she admit her feelings? | T |
| Tumn | Unrequited? Think Again | 4809 | Scully gets jealous of Mulder's new chick-a-dee, but it turns out to be as real wake-up call for Mulder, with the help of a dark alley, some Bryan Adams, and a shower. | R |
| wickedshadowscry | Bitch¹ | 2975 | Scully is Jealous | N |
| WildwingSuz | Assumptions¹ | 7323 | Mulder dating a suspect from an earlier case finally makes Scully see what she has at hand. | M |
| Writergal2000 | Put To Rest | 7022 | On a snowy night, Mulder contemplates the meaning of his dream sequences during his brain surgery. What he comes to realize is shocking not only to his partner, but to himself. And he not only tells the truth, but also hears some truth from the only person who really matters to him. | T |
| wtfmulder | The Condom Story (aka Pocket Guts) | 2833 | Set during s6. Mulder and Scully have a lot to work in their relationship -- before it even gets to happen. Prompt: how would Scully react if Mulder dropped an open condom wrapper in front of her? | M |
| XAngel (Emily Sim) | Cabinets & Desks & Chairs, Oh My!¹ | 6965 | Scully is sick of watching Mulder lap up the attention given to him by other women. | N |
| Xenoprobe | Until Theres Nothing Left To Say¹ | 10180 | After Mulder rejects Scully's findings on Agt. Fowley's possible duplicity, Scully nurses her emotional wounds with some bourbon. | R |
| Xphila | Jealousy Is Fear | 3551 | Scully is Jealous of Diana Fowley. | T |
